Articles worth reading
Photo Courtesy of QCPD Public Information Office

QCPD arrests 23 illegal drug suspects

account_balanceQuezon City access_time4 days ago

Quezon City Police District (QCPD) Director, Police Brigadier General Nicolas D Torre III, announced the arrest of 23 drug suspects and confiscation of P421,700.00 worth of illegal drugs in separate buy-bust operations conducted by different police s...

Photo Courtesy of Netflix

Kim Seon Ho arriving in Manila in January 

account_balanceMetro Manila access_time4 days ago

The seat plan and ticket prices for Kim Seon Ho's Manila fan meet in January are here, according to a report by GMA News. Tickets range from P2,000 for General Admission to P12,500 for VIP A, according to PULP Live World's announcement Thu...

Photo courtesy of DOST Region III

DTI holds matching event for Central Luzon SMEs 

account_balanceMetro Manila access_time4 days ago

Small and medium enterprises (SMEs) in Central Luzon received a big boost in upgrading their businesses through collaborative innovations, according to a report by Philippine News Agency. Through the 2022 THRIVE Central Luzon Innovation Summit,...

Metro News

Photo Courtesy of mack2happy / Getty Images

Global experts dismiss report on alleged youth epidemic

account_balanceMetro News account_circleNoah James chat_bubble_outline0 Comments

The Coalition of Asia Pacific Tobacco Harm Reduction Advocates (CAPHRA) and global health experts have dismissed as "naïve" and "harmful" a report published by a regional lobby group about the so-called youth epidemic in a bid to undermine scientific evidence in favor of reduced-risk products.

Nancy Loucas, Executive Director of CAPHRA, described the report entitled "Today''s Teens, Tomorrow''s Customers" as a product of perception by a group that is funded by industry, including pharmaceutical interests that "justifies its existence by creating a youth ''epidemic'' in order to remain relevant."

Loucas said the report published by Southeast Asia Tobacco Control Alliance (SEATCA) for World No Tobacco Day could no longer deny the truth about the effectiveness of tobacco harm reduction and reduced-risk products such as e-cigarettes, heat-not-burn tobacco products and snus in making smokers switch. The report argued that "banning the manufacture, importation, promotion, distribution, sale and use of these products is still the most comprehensive approach" to regulating e-cigarettes and heat-not-burn tobacco products.


Loucas said SEATCA''s argument that "e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products are being used to entice youth to take up vaping and potentially smoking" is the opposite of what happens in different countries when smoking rates are on the decline.

She said that even the World Health Organization (WHO), after months of demonizing tobacco harm reduction and reduced-risk products, has recently come out with a theme report on World Vape Day stating that, "while it is expected that use of EN & NNDS [electronic nicotine and non-nicotine delivery systems] in these groups might increase their health risks, non-pregnant adult smokers who completely and promptly switch from combustible tobacco cigarettes to use of unadulterated and appropriately regulated EN & NNDS alone might reduce their health risks."

"The most interesting point in the WHO theme report is that WHO also expended a lot of space on the scientific knowledge of e-cigarettes, with a view to the public having more knowledge about e-cigarettes. The very same public knowledge held by the consumers of CAPHRA''s member organizations, who are shut out of any discussion around tobacco control and harm reduction with their own governments," Loucas said.

David Sweanor, a Canadian lawyer who has worked in global public health efforts on tobacco for over 30 years, said the SEATCA report "shows extraordinary levels of naivety about consumers, nicotine, the tobacco industry and the history of successful efforts to reduce risks for a vast array of other products and services."

Sweanor said the report diminishes "an unparalleled opportunity to save millions of lives and to relegate cigarettes to the ashtray of history."

"Inhaling cigarette smoke is extraordinarily toxic, resulting in over 20,000 global deaths daily. We have known for decades that the harm is from the smoke, not the nicotine, and we now have viable ways to give the nicotine people need or want without the inhalation of the toxic products of combustion.

"To see this situation as a reason to protect cigarettes by banning safer alternatives rather than using these safer products to attack the cigarette business is breathtakingly ignorant. It would be like dealing with a cholera epidemic by seeking to ban clean water or dealing with automobiles by banning safety features," he said.

"I am shocked by just how counterproductive a paper they have produced. One might think novices in the field would seek advice from people like me. In this case, they not only failed to do that but defamed me. They clearly have an agenda, and it is advantaging the cigarette business rather than public health," said Sweanor.

"At a very basic ethical level, they should prominently disclose their funding sources. When people purporting to be health advocates take positions so oppositional to public health, the public and regulators have a right to know of vested interests," he said.

Konstantinos Farsalinos, a cardiologist, senior researcher at the University of Patras in Greece and Highly Cited expert on tobacco harm reduction, said, "the SEACTA position to ban harm reduction nicotine products is an unfortunate display of unrealism and failure to understand and present the totality of evidence."

"This is one of the many Bloomberg-funded organizations whose campaigns are actually protecting tobacco cigarette sales and profits since their proposals will result in the creation of a monopoly for tobacco cigarettes—the most harmful and deadliest nicotine product," Farsalinos said.

"Banning the substantially less harmful, non-combustible nicotine products while allowing the sales of tobacco cigarettes is ironic, unreasonable, harmful for public health and a direct violation of human rights and of the 1986 WHO Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion," he said.

Professor Tikki Pangestu, a visiting professor at Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy in the National University of Singapore, said that by conflating the benefits for smokers who want to quit, with as yet unproven allegations of risks to youth, the report does a disservice to smokers and is an abuse of the human right to access better health.

"A more open and objective mind to the evidence, and a willingness to try out THR in addition to traditional strategies such as NRTs and cessation services, could go a long way to saving the lives of more than 1 billion smokers globally, most of whom live in LMICs [low and middle-income countries] of the developing world," Pangestu said.

Dr. Alex Wodak, an emeritus consultant of Alcohol and Drug Service at St. Vincent''s Hospital and president of the Australian Drug Law Reform Foundation, said tobacco harm reduction deserves to gain attention, not opposition, in low and middle-income countries (LMICs) where smoking results in 8 million deaths each year.

"Most of the worldwide 1 billion smoking-related deaths for the remainder of this century will also be in LMICs. The fact that LMICs are where most of the tobacco-related harm is now and even more so, is going to be in the future, are very good reasons to make advocacy in LMICs for THR the highest priority," Wodak said.

"LMICs have younger populations and higher smoking rates than rich countries. These are all the more good reasons for making THR advocacy in LMICs a top priority," he said.

date_rangeDate Published
2 years ago
shareShare article
folder_openArticle tags
content_copyCategorized under

Share your thoughts with us

Related Articles

PDEA seizes illegal drugs from a house in Ayala Alabang 

account_balanceMuntinlupa chrome_reader_mode6 days ago

Muntinlupa Mayor Ruffy Biazon said new security measures were proposed for the exclusive Ayala Alabang Village after the Philippine Drug Enforcement Agency (PDEA) seized 20 kilos of suspected shabu shabu (methamphetamine hydrochloride) worth P136 mil...

Photo Courtesy of

House committee approves bill on Maharlika Investment Fund 

account_balanceMetro Manila chrome_reader_mode4 days ago

A measure seeking the creation of a sovereign wealth fund (SWF) to maximize the profitability of investible government assets for the benefit of all Filipinos hurdled committee level at the House of Representatives, according to a report by Phil...

Ginebra import Justin Brownlee / PNA

House approves Brownlee's Filipino citizenship 

account_balanceMetro Manila chrome_reader_mode6 days ago

The House of Representatives on Tuesday approved on third and final reading a measure seeking to grant Filipino citizenship to Barangay Ginebra resident import Justin Brownlee, according to a report by Philippine News Agency. With 274 affirmati...

Money supply expected to sustain growth

account_balanceMetro Manila chrome_reader_mode4 days ago

Growth of domestic liquidity or M3 is projected to remain in the mid-single digits in the near term, an economist said Thursday, noting excess liquidity in the system that is being siphoned off through the various central bank facilities, according t...

Click on the article to continue reading
Quezon City adopts no contact apprehension system Red Cross pushes saliva test Vaccines from COVAX to arrive in Q1 Makati Shangri-La to close doors on Feb. 1 Cities in NCR to start vaccination simultaneously Mother, girlfriend of Filipino infected with UK variant also test positive Send Press Release MNC Facebook Page MNC Twitter Page MNC Instagram Page LGU Spotlight Barangay Front Business Sports Entertainment Metro Gen Metro Feature